No homeowner wants to hear that a tree needs to come down. Trees add beauty, shade, and value to properties across the West Island of Montreal. But there are times when removal is the safest and most responsible option — for your family, your home, and your neighbours.
Visible Signs of Decay and Disease
One of the most obvious indicators is widespread decay. Look for large fungal growths (conks or shelf fungi) at the base of the trunk, soft or crumbling wood, and hollowed-out sections. In Pointe-Claire and Beaconsfield, aging silver maples are especially prone to internal rot that can go unnoticed until a major limb fails. If more than 50% of the trunk is hollow, the tree is structurally compromised and should be assessed by a certified arborist.
Leaning and Root Problems
A tree that has suddenly started leaning — especially after a storm — may have root failure. Check the soil around the base for heaving or cracking. In Kirkland and Dorval, where clay soils are common, root systems can be undermined by poor drainage and freeze-thaw cycles. A tree leaning more than 15 degrees from vertical with exposed or broken roots is a serious hazard.
Dead Branches and Crown Dieback
If more than half the crown is dead or leafless during the growing season, the tree is in severe decline. Dead branches — sometimes called "widow makers" — can fall without warning. This is a particular concern for properties near sidewalks, driveways, and play areas. Homeowners in Hudson and Saint-Lazare with large rural lots should watch mature oaks and elms carefully for progressive crown thinning.
Proximity to Structures and Power Lines
Sometimes a healthy tree still needs removal because of where it is growing. Trees pressing against foundations, growing into roof lines, or entangled with Hydro-Québec power lines pose ongoing risks. Municipal bylaws in many West Island cities require permits before removal — your arborist can handle the paperwork for you.
When in Doubt, Get a Professional Assessment
Tree removal is irreversible, so it is important to get an expert opinion before making a decision. At Service d'Arbres Brandse, we provide honest assessments and will always recommend preservation when it is safe to do so. If removal is necessary, we handle everything from permits to stump grinding. Call us at (438) 365-5410 for a free evaluation anywhere in the West Island.